Public Image

While I agree with a lot of your points, specifically about punk honing the same spirit as rock 'n' roll, I think you're missing a very essential aspect of the punk ethos in that punk, at its heart, was about not confining oneself to a uniform mentality. It was sort of existential in that way, partnered with its obsession with wilful self-definition. Punk was about progress, it was about proposing new ideas even if it meant you had to be a bit violent with it, and while that may seem absurd in light of the spirit of '77 (ie. sped up Chuck Berry riffs), that stripping down was necessary for the musical landscape to expand its mind artistically. Had that not happened, rock music would have continued to be a very bedenimed, 20-minute drum solo sort of thing, which oftentimes isn't so much progressive as it is complacent and indulgent. This is why The Clash and John Lydon were able to thrive where other less imaginative bands weren't. they didn't confine themselves to any guidelines. The Clash had adopted the sounds of dub reggae, rock 'n' roll, soul, funk, rap, musique concrete, and everything in between by London Calling and Sandinista, and even much of the post-debut singles and Give 'Em Enough rope. John Lydon formed PiL, which was infinitely more interesting than the Sex Pistols in my opinion and, as you said, informed by dub and noise, etc. What I'm saying is that The Clash and Sex Pistols (or rather, John Lydon), if anything, LEAST reflect the commercialization of punk because, for the most part, they were fiercely independent in how they made their music, and because they managed to grow where less notable bands of the scene fell flat on their face. As far as being on major labels goes, the fact of the matter is that the '70s were a time where you pretty much needed that if you wanted your music to reach anybody outside of your country. Hell, The Clash's debut didn't even come to America until '79, long after the fact. And, for the record, saying The Clash adapted their sound to the Pistols is vastly reductive. The Clash owes to the Pistols, sure, but the Pistols owe to The Ramones and New York Dolls, who owe to The Stooges and The Beach Boys and Chuck Berry and Jerry Lee Lewis, and so on and so forth.