Is This Love? Lyrics
Don't want me anymore
You're with him and you don't even know
And singing sad, sad songs
And wishing you were gone
Oh, is this love?
Is this love?
Or should I close the door?
And seeing only red
And wishing you were dead
Oh, is this love?
Is this love?
Oh, no is this love? I don't thing so
Is this love?
Or should I
Or should I, should I
Should I close the door?
Should I close the door? Aah, I fooled myself
Yea, alright, okay
Is this love? I don't thing so
(Is this love?)
Is this love?
Oh, no is this love?
Is this love?
Or should I
Or should I
Or should I, should I
Should I close the door?

This song is about a man who was in a great relationship with some girl until she left him for some other guy. He's still in love with her and appears to be very upset that she is with someone else. He is still leaving his door open for her to return through, but he is wondering if it is a futile effort.

my take on this song: John McCrea is really really pissed at his ex-girlfriend for leaving and he is sarcastically asking himself 'is this love?' because he used to really love her and he's wondering what happened to their love because what he's feeling now certainly isn't.

I could swear he says: Oh poo myself instead of: Ah, I fooled myself
am I the only one?

i love the way cake is one of the only alternative bands to incorperate horns into their music

To tunasandwich77: let's flesh this out a little further and also assume John's ruminating on what he did to drive this woman into another man's arms, thus that intense self-righteous anger and pain he's expressing. Self-incrimination can be such a dangerous emotion which clouds any rational thought--and believe me, rationality has just been kicked to the curb!

it's about a guy that's pissed