sort form Submissions:
submissions
Spock's Beard – The Great Nothing Lyrics 4 years ago
The song is about the modern version of Icarus, possibly a personal allegory for Neal's career at the time. The protagonist ("the boy") is someone who has higher aspirations in his field, (music, in Neal's case) but he of course will "never have commercial success", because he is striving for a goal that is deeper and more important (i.e. deep and meaningful music, in contrast with superficial pop music).

The protagonist ultimately burns out in his career and begins to indulge in self-destructive tendencies (i.e. drinking) because his goal is unattainable. From the outside, people begin to resent him for his ideology, but still attempt to help him find a workable path forward ("I've worked with him closely...Before it's too late"). Ultimately, the protagonist is too headstrong, and spirals out into complete and utter nihilism (The Great Nothing).

submissions
Shadow Gallery – Warcry Lyrics 4 years ago
This song is clearly about environmental impact. The narrator blames previous generations/governments/corporations for getting us into this nightmare (verse 1/2), though the particular adversary is not named specifically.

Verse 3 goes into a bit of nihilistic anger towards this adversary, and claims that "our spirits" (whatever loose environmental coalition that represents) "are not weak like you" (i.e. the adversary).

Verse 4 builds this protagonistic coalition into a metaphorical environmental army.

Verse 5 describes continues to rail on the adversary characterizing their "truces" as "sacrilegious and deceitful". In the last two lines the narrator admits that he tries to compartmentalize this element of his persona, but he now he "fights for [his] name".

Of course lyrics are only part of the analysis here (may be some transcriptional errors here; my harmonic ear has a lot of room for improvement). From a musical standpoint, there is an interesting juxtaposition of a relatively light and positive melody (a simple I-V-IV-V cadence in F-major) for the first 2 verses, which contrast to the dark tone of the lyrics. I think this is in reference to the general feeling of complacency we have when it comes to the environment, even when we know intellectually (i.e. from the reading the lyrics) things are going south.

Verse 3 marks a shift in musical tone and tonality, with the addition of distorted guitar and parallel minor key change (I think it's v-IV-bIII-bIII, which would be harmonic minor, but feel free to correct me). At this point, we are seeing the effects of climate change firsthand, and really feeling the effect intimately. However, in the second half of this verse we have another cadence change (bIII-ii-bIII-bIII?) to coincide with the pleading, to ultimately land back into major tonality (I) on "you", with a tension resolving into the new key. This transition seems to indicate hope, a sense that we can actually do something about this problem.

Verse 4 is effectively the "Warcry" section (back in minor), and the anger builds until we reach the "battle" (i.e. guitar solo).

Verse 5: This verse is in C# melodic minor, but the first two lines land on the relative major chord (v-IV-bIII). Despite this, the bIII doesn't seem to have tonic function to my ear, possibly because the vocal line is hanging on the fifth of the chord (i.e. the m7). The second half (i-v-IV-bVII-bVI-V) ends on the V, giving the characteristic leading tone of melodic minor for increased dramatic tension.

Anyway, that's my take on a deep cut from an underappreciated band. I hope the 3 people out there who are excited about this song appreciate this interpretation.

* This information can be up to 15 minutes delayed.