Lyric discussion by atreyun 

The song alludes to "The Reality" of hell. It is a song to fellow Christians, "We were created to set an example. So what is this, what is this?". Christianity teaches that we are the body of Christ and Christians should be the example to the world as to how they should live. But "The Reality" is that we are not the perfect example that we should be. The chorus is:

"(It seems like every soul Has been sold for a dollar or less. I guess we'll never know How good it could have been.) How good it could have been!"

Meaning that everybody, including Christians, have sold their innocence for so cheap, and we may never know just how good our lives could have been if we lived the life that God wants us to live.

Matty is an avid Christian and when he writes,

"Follow me or back out now. Follow me with all your heart Or back out now!"

I believe that he is quite literally saying follow me on the path to Christ otherwise I don't want you in my Reality.

An error occured.