Lyric discussion by JmanroXD 

Cover art for I Guess You're Right lyrics by Posies, The

What I think is the guy is confessing to the girl that she is right.

He says he's speechless on her words.

she had convinced him its worth living

he won't leave her in their relationship

and now he's okay, he's okay

If he seems more than he looks

He guesses she's right

if he's in her imagination

He guesses she's right

He admits she's smart

He likes how she breaks down his personality

he could believe he had died before

since right now he's needy

Like people only speak for him

if he seems like more than he looks

He thinks she's right

if he's in her fantasies

He thinks she's right

if he appears in her dreams in a deep sleep

he thinks she's right

if he never lets her leave he'll know she's so so right

if he seems more than he looks

He guesses she's right

If he's in her fantasies

He guesses she's right

if he claims her as his only own

Would that be right?

if he never lets her leave he'll know her so so right

Take it as a clue

Listen to him make love to her

accept his lust as proof of his love for her

Take his heart... He's taken her

((that's how I break down each of the lyrics in the song in order. Its just how I see it. Love the song btw.))