This is one of my favorite DW songs (huge fan since 1992, been to 15 or so shows in 6 cities), and it's so musically beautiful. It sounds like a love song, but it is far from a happy one. I think it's quite simple--there was a romantic tryst and he fell in love, but she didn't. And she relies upon the knowledge that she didn't explicitly promise him anything (she was "honest" and "clear from the start"). But her actions made him feel like she loved him. He likens it to whispering a secret (ie.: "I love you") and letting him "believe it, to please [him], though it just wasn't true". She's also "gifted" at what she does, so he thinks she's done this before . . . letting a guy fall in love with her, making him feel loved, when she really doesn't. But again, she relies on the fact that she never promised him anything. It's actually kind of harsh . . . and sad . . . and beautiful. And very much like something that took me probably 10 years to get over myself!
drewhon December 05, 2007 Link
-
No Replies Log in to reply