Swan Lake – All Fires

General CommentThere is a clear religious undertone going on in this song. I think Terressa is the name of the god that this community all loves so much, as it is reitterated over again. At first you get the idea that because this disaster is destroying these people, it is a message of religious faith being worthless, because your God won't stop such a terrible thing. But, if they never worshipped Teressa, they would not have built the steeple, and without the steeple, all would have parished in the flood instead of half. In the end though, it is the same message from "They took a vote." The natural cycle of life, that some things have to die so that others can live on. Humanity being compared to the life of a fire. A fire literally burns itself alive until it has used up all its fuel, and then ceases to exist, but if it does not burn it will never exist in the first place. "All fires have to burn alive to live."

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @Chase Elliot

General CommentAnybody who has read Kundera's "Unbearable Lightness of Being" should be able to make the connection to the "It's Teresa that you love the best" line.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @CoryOOreo

General CommentI don't see why the biblical references, each of which worth parsing individually, have to add up to some explicitly religious theme or message. They each have their own reasons for being in the song, but I see no connecting pattern. Divine imagery is just a smart, easy way for Krug to add emotional weight and epic feel to the mythical narrative he is shaping (as if that guitar wasn't enough.)

Though it yet remains turbid in my mind, I feel pretty sure that this song is, somewhere below all those layers of wailing prettiness, using gender to highlight the essential tragedy of humankind. Notice first that both the narrator and the addressed are male. Notice also that every mention of Theresa, the unattainable, unidentifiable maiden at the center of this cryptic ballad, is prompted by some catastrophe (heartbreak, mass drowning, partial dismemberment/perpetual immolation.) And the Mason's wife swims "for" her daughter, not "to" her, implying that the struggling mother fails to make it to the girl it in time. Given the chivalry of those times when towns had steeples, Masons, and no plans or tools to mollify a flood, the five hundred wood floats would have been given chiefly to women and their children. Every woman in this tale (excluding your sister, who, to you, isn't effectively a woman at all, because, well, she's your sister, although the syntax of the lines does almost seem to blame her for your lack of brothers...) has someone suffering for her sake. This isn't a sexist imprecation of the female, though. Women are doing the suffering too. And, because the purity and beauty of woman renders life itself both possible and worthwhile, people will die for her willingly, and still love her even after. So, though Eve will make him Fall, Adam gladly yanks out his rib. Man must endure incompleteness, death, heartche, lust, loneliness, just to keep his other half around. He never quite seems to get the girl, though. In fact, he's been burning for her for millennia. Love hurts, ya know?

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @uburoi

General Comment++ sethbrown - such a brilliant line.

That's a great verse, but the second to last line of the song is hands down the best - "All fires have to burn alive to live."

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @mswer

General Commentbeautiful song.

as far as the meaning goes,
the singer is in a relationship with this wonderful girl (Teresa) that everyone adores. There is a disaster in the relationship (symbolized by the flood), and he knows that even if he tears apart everything sacred to him (church steeple), its not certain that things will work out (about a 50/50 chance).

but hes saying that he must give it everything he has no matter what.
all fires must burn alive to live

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @universal remonster

General CommentKrug pulls a Destroyer in stealing from himself and re-using the line "all fires have to burn alive to live," almost verbatim; it originally appeared in "They Took a Vote and Said No" on "Shut Up I Am Dreaming." And he slyly precedes it with "I've said it before and I'll say it again," so clearly he knows what he's up to. I wonder if his working with Dan Bejar has anything to do with these shenanigans. ;)

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @valrus

General Comment"You have good friends
You have a lover
When friendships end
You will still love her"

So, so beautiful. I cannot wait for this album.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @proposals

General Comment"Five hundred pieces
Means five hundred float.
One thousand people means
Five hundred don’t"

i love this verse. this is a gorgeous song. i guess it's about a shipwreck.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @sethbrown

General Comment"Five hundred pieces
Means five hundred float.
One thousand people means
Five hundred don’t.
And it’s Teresa they love the best."

Definitely the best verse.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @Colin B.

General Commentprobably one of the best songs on the album

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @peechlove