Who Knew

This is one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard! I'm totally in love with it. It's the kind of song that almost makes me start crying, whenever I'm listening to it. Seriously, everybody should buy it... *Heart*

Yes..you can give a lot of meanings to this song. I think that it can be a about her and some ex boyfriend..who was her friend too..And then..you know..when we're in love we say always "forever" and that stuff...but...

I now find this song ironic because I walked around singing it for years, and yeah I'd knew exactly what she was saying but it never fully hit me until just now. My boyfriend and I had been together for five nearly perfect years. The problem was that there was quite a controversial age difference. A six year gap (me being 15 and him being 21, before you say anything, we were long distance, not sexually active and didn't jump into a relationship. We were really good friends who made sure the other didn't commit suicide and we just fell for each other). It's hard getting dirty looks because of the person you love's age but I knew what was true. He loved me too. I looked forward to turning 18 and moving in with him and spending my life with him. And for those five years he did too. I'll save you the whole sob story and say we officially split last night. And I can't even hate him because no matter what, he's perfect in my eyes. And if he's happy, I'll do my best to keep him that way even if it does hurt. He got me through alot of hurt, and I defended him from everything I could and kept him alive. I thought we'd be forever. A regular fairy tale and I argued down everyone who said otherwise. Who feels like an ass now? Hah. He is and always be my angel,my first love, my dream guy. But the future isn't set in stone. Last time I let myself get blinded. Who knew? Three Cheers for Five Heart wrenching, constant texting, picture sending years.

• 4 Replies Log in to reply

what's amazing about this song is that it could bring out something in the deepest place inside everyone,at least according to most comments i have seen so far and my own case. I actually havent been thru any deaths or anything emotionally devastating.But everytime when i sing to the video of the song i just cant help crying belting out the notes

Pink's close friend Sekou Harris died of a heroin overdose when they were only 14. The tragedy inspired Pink’s 2006 song, “Who Knew.” source: nydailynews.com/entertainment/gossip/… Pink in the London Daily Mail May 26th 2006 said this song is about losing a loved one to drugs: "My life was insane, I was (in her youth) out of control and doing lots of stupid things. Some of my friends were selling crack, and I got into drugs too. I've always been honest about that, although I don't like going into details. I've got lots of young fans and I wouldn't want to give them any ideas. I found a friend dead from a drug overdose when I was 14. He was a male friend, not a boyfriend. Most of the people at the funeral were just children. It should have been a wake-up call for me, but it wasn't." According to Pink, the song is about "the grieving process. You can look at somebody, he might be right there, and the next Monday he might not be."

This is great song, and yeah it's really sad. At first I thought it was about like a relationship that she thought would last forever because of the line "That last kiss I'll cherish until we meet again" and because of the "my darling" stuff at the end, you know like I thought it was about a person who claimed that they'd be together forever and then they just take off. But the thing about the heroin overdose makes sense too. This song gets me all choked up too. It is really powerful, that's what I like about Pink, her emotional songs all feel so real especially since i can relate to so many of the situations in her songs.

I am IN LOVE with this song From when i got the new album i fell in love with it I hate how the video is a gurl and her boyfriend cause i take it as best friends It reminds me so much of my best friend I thought we'd be friends for life and we broke apart 3 years ago & i miss her lots. And yeah the thing about her friend is right. Also, i love her look in the vid! Pink rules =D

jamiie3x0o , I don't think she means blessing as when somebody dies, but more as something you're grateful for. Example, I'm grateful for my wonderful dog, my house, my good health, and a family that cares. Therefore, I'm counting my blessings. I associate this song with an ex boyfriend, because I was in a relationship where he'd promise me that we'd be forever, and I took his word. And when somebody I knew would tell me different, I'd get defensive and ignore them for awhile.

i fkin love this sng, yeah, cud b bout losin sum1, but i relate 2 it in the sense of a bf, if sum1 wud hav sed 2 me that we wudnt b 2getha now, id hav hit them, like, she loved him now they not 2getha n she misses him. well, thats how this sng makes me feel bout my x =0( v.v.v gud sng tho

I feel this song. I feel like she is talking about 'friendship' more than an actual romantic relationship. How you would give everything to someone and get so attached to them, when all of the sudden they are not there anymore, they are some part of the past. It's so hurting, yet so true...I miss my former close friends so much, they are not replaceable...and it breaks my heart.