The Decemberists – The Engine Driver

General CommentOkay, meaning now.

I think that this is a song comprised of several different characters (obviously) with most of the focus given to the writer (who I think is, in some part, Meloy) -- it's very simple with lots of repetition, but I think it comes down to one moral -- All of these people are something by their very nature; it's in their bones, it's who they are, and they're calling out, "If you don't love me let me go" -- or, if you don't love me for who I really am, let me go.

Going deeper, you could look at the writer and think, he's trying to rid this love from his bones, so maybe she's become a part of him (assuming the first person is male, sorry) as well; or, he is becoming a part of her, as in "I am the heart that you call home". Yet, he's just a writer of fictions; he's trying to write her out of his life, but she won't let go.

So they're all people with dilemmas of the heart -- all having to do with the permanent *who* they are perhaps conflicting with their love's perception of them; or anyone's perception of them for that matter.

In any case, it's a beautiful song. Love it.

• 2 Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @trisweb
  +2

  I kind of think the point is all the characters, the engine driver, the lineman, the moneylender, all know who they are. They tell their jobs and seem to accept what they are.
  
  But the writer doesn't know who he is. He just writes to keep away a person who he loved. He doesn't really have that much of an identity separate from her because whenever he talks about himself, he relates it to this other person.
  
  Just how I see it :-)

  Flag EvilGiraffeon August 14, 2009  

  0

  @trisweb If you are right it's one of the deepest songs in existence, even now ... OH NO I WAS 5 WHEN YOU MADE THIS COMMENT-

  Flag limakorolevaon September 24, 2018  

General CommentThis song could be about a songwriter/musician/decemberists frontman.

Each of the professions he lists in the verses are various parts of being a touring musician.
"engine driver": touring across a country must feel.
"county lineman" or electrician: dealing with the equipment.
"moneylender": the business side of music.

and of course, a writer using fiction to work out a past relationship isn't a stretch of the imagine.

maybe colin's most autobigraphy song.
or i could be completely wrong.

either way, wonderful song.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @sethbrown

General CommentI feel as if it's about a writer trying to get over this girl.
He keeps writing these stories and pouring himself into these different characters
and no matter who he becomes he still doesn't get the girl.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @ATadBitEerie

General CommentIt's about that girl that you want but will never get, for whatever reason. Still, even knowing this, the love that you feel stays. Meloy is shrieking "if you don't love me let me go", but the love still stays, despite the fact that the writer has "written pages upon pages trying to rid you from my bones." A nasty little spot to be in. Part of me is starting to think that there is only ONE charactor...I'll post more on that once I think about it some more.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @five_to_one

General Comment^^I think that may be reading a bit much into it, as song's that Colin has written about mothers aren't necessarily reflections on his mother. His writing style is rarely ever autobiographical, it's mostly story telling.

That said...the engine driver in question is experiencing a feeling that I think five_to_one described best. Hopelessness, but at the same time, something deep inside him ("my bones") just won't let go, no matter what he does to try to get rid of her ("I've written pages upon pages").

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @Ne Plus Ultra

General CommentWhen the song says 'Trying to rid you from my bones', I don't interpret that as trying to forget a girl. I'm writing a fiction book as well, and it's partially to just get the story out of me.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @brisingr47

General Commentthe subject seems to be recalling a life, perhaps richly lived, but ultimately empty.

in his youth, he is an engine driver - in other words, a railroad engineer. it's not a bad life, but it is indeed a lonely one, with long, isolated shifts. he asks himself if his work is compatible with a life lived alongside the girl he loves. in the final line of the verse, he notes "she's a long one" - is he talking about the shift, or the woman? she's a long shot, either way. the tone here is uncertain, but there's a touch of hope.

later in life, the subject is a lineman; a less rewarding job, perhaps, but more conducive to living as a family man. he's taken up the family trade and left behind his old life. he alludes to having grandchildren here, specifically a grandson. it seems, then, that he is married, although he is still dreaming of this other woman. "there are power lines in our bloodlines," he notes, wondering if his grandson is doomed to the same life he has lived thus far.

an older man, the subject works now as a money lender. he has amassed riches, perhaps from a life of hard and yet ultimately unrewarding work. in his view, life has been unkind to him. perhaps his current spouse is with him only for his money - is he remarrying, or has his marriage always been this unhappy? "take my hand for tender," he says. there's a sense of defeat, and of unrelenting loneliness.

at the end of it all, he recalls his life in writing. perhaps he has written all this time, only intensifying the strength of his unrequited love. he has lived many lives, all of them fictions in a sense; rich, but not the reality he has wanted. in each of them, he hopes that perhaps he will be loved in return. the woman in question has taken root in his heart and in his bones, and try as he might, he can't write her out. perhaps he doesn't want to. note the conditional: "if you don't love me, let me go". is he still holding out for that long shot? he is still looking for the life in which he will be loved in return. he knows he may never find it.

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @chronostasis

General Comment"And I've written pages upon pages
Trying to rid you from my bones"

I get chills every time. :)

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @odalisque

General Commentjust beautiful. My favorite on Picaresque

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @Bryia_026

General Commenti love this song. i totally agree with five to one. i feel bad for him, especially cause im in pretty much the same position.....

• No Replies Log in to reply
  
    There was an error.

  @jazzy88