Lyric discussion by AtotheBtotheC 

They won't ruin their careers by telling you what the song is about or they wrote it high and don't understand what their subconscious minds delivered. Most likely the latter.

The hangman is sung in a similar manner to "Anna Molly" by Incubus. Anna Molly or Anomaly?

Hangman, hey man or hymen?

"Hangman we played rubber soul with a razor blade"

Hangman is a coat hanger and an abortionist, the rubber soul is a condom and the blade is an allegory for murder and destroying one's rubber (relative morality) soul.

"It was a long joke till the punch line came."

A long joke is a penis, and then it came.

"Hangman we played double dutch with a hand grenade"

Once again the hangman is both an abortionist and a coat hanger.

Double dutch is not just a rope game. It is slang regarding using a condom and the pill at the same time to prevent pregnancy. The fact that they were using a hand grenade means there was no protection.

"They let us go but we lost one"

She lost a child as it got torn to pieces by a mass murdering hangman (abortionist/coat hanger).

"Can you read my mind?"

This song equates abortion with murder. Whether it was a conscious decision or drug influenced is unknown but the deeper meaning is in there.

An error occured.