The chorus of any song will tell you what a song is about. Everything else is a supporting statement. With that thought, I believe this song is about social programs. This song is entirely political.
Aside from the chorus, here are other social program references:
If we just took a step back
A bigger picture we might see
Perhaps the man in the gutter
Is not so different from you
Come in out of the cold
Forget all that you know
Because there's always been room
By the fire for you
Come in out of the cold
Next, we have this:
All the way from the towers
High above the glass ceilinged tombs
Tell themselves that they've earned this
By working hard and playing by the rules
But this is only part true
A dangerous trick played on me and you
And so, like a practical joke
We pulled on these bootstraps
So hard that they broke
Will you believe them?
Is this an over-reaching arm?
Or is this compassion?
Is this a handout undeserved?
Or a just reparation?
They're talking about how Republican politicians like to talk about how we're all the same- hard working Americans (they include themselves in this) - and how we don't want those tax hikes (that are meant to support social programs) b/c they worked hard for their money. Why should anyone else get what they "worked hard for?" Meanwhile, they leave out the fact that under the proposed tax hikes, only the upper tier see the biggest tax increase(themselves); while the people who could actually benefit from these social programs are duped into believing the Republican lies and vote against something that could actually help them. The wealthy don't have to pay their fair share, and so, the wealthy stay wealthy, and the poor stay poor. THIS is how the little guy is kept down. That's what this song is about.
I think it would be entirely hypocritical for the band to say that you have to be wealthy to make wealth. Were they wealthy before they became big? How much money have they made? Do you see where I'm going? I think Rise Against is much deeper than that. You need to understand WHY, instead of making blanket statements. This song is very nicely done & delivers are powerful message.
Also, I don't think he's talking about himself when he says he's through believing. Maybe going into character of someone who woke up from the lies. Great closing line for a character in the music video.
I really like your interpretation too. Though I'm not american and I'm no expert in domestic politics in the US, I feel that this applys all over the world. Disparity is nowdays created by people who don't really have an understanding about the lives and problems of "regular people".
I really like your interpretation too. Though I'm not american and I'm no expert in domestic politics in the US, I feel that this applys all over the world. Disparity is nowdays created by people who don't really have an understanding about the lives and problems of "regular people".
Anyways, one of the best songs in the album which is btw much better than its predecessor :)
Anyways, one of the best songs in the album which is btw much better than its predecessor :)
I'm not American either, it seems to me like it's summing up whats wrong with society.
The first part focuses on 'being born with a silver spoon' and your chances in life being related to what your parents did and the social class your family is in. This is backed up by:
''They feast from the lines
While we settle from crumbs''
This is obviously talking about how the rich eat from linen tablecloths with ordinary people settle for the scraps that are left.
I'm not American either, it seems to me like it's summing up whats wrong with society.
The first part focuses on 'being born with a silver spoon' and your chances in life being related to what your parents did and the social class your family is in. This is backed up by:
''They feast from the lines
While we settle from crumbs''
This is obviously talking about how the rich eat from linen tablecloths with ordinary people settle for the scraps that are left.
''Is this a handout undeserved?
Or a just reparation?''
This asks whether some of the state handouts are generous or to keep citizens quite.
''If theres a God you better pray
That this sleeping giant never wakes''
This is an eerie foreshadowing of EU Riots, and the internet fueled Anon and Occupy protests.
The chorus of any song will tell you what a song is about. Everything else is a supporting statement. With that thought, I believe this song is about social programs. This song is entirely political.
Aside from the chorus, here are other social program references:
If we just took a step back A bigger picture we might see Perhaps the man in the gutter Is not so different from you
Come in out of the cold Forget all that you know Because there's always been room By the fire for you Come in out of the cold
Next, we have this:
All the way from the towers High above the glass ceilinged tombs Tell themselves that they've earned this By working hard and playing by the rules But this is only part true A dangerous trick played on me and you And so, like a practical joke We pulled on these bootstraps So hard that they broke
Will you believe them? Is this an over-reaching arm? Or is this compassion? Is this a handout undeserved? Or a just reparation?
They're talking about how Republican politicians like to talk about how we're all the same- hard working Americans (they include themselves in this) - and how we don't want those tax hikes (that are meant to support social programs) b/c they worked hard for their money. Why should anyone else get what they "worked hard for?" Meanwhile, they leave out the fact that under the proposed tax hikes, only the upper tier see the biggest tax increase(themselves); while the people who could actually benefit from these social programs are duped into believing the Republican lies and vote against something that could actually help them. The wealthy don't have to pay their fair share, and so, the wealthy stay wealthy, and the poor stay poor. THIS is how the little guy is kept down. That's what this song is about.
I think it would be entirely hypocritical for the band to say that you have to be wealthy to make wealth. Were they wealthy before they became big? How much money have they made? Do you see where I'm going? I think Rise Against is much deeper than that. You need to understand WHY, instead of making blanket statements. This song is very nicely done & delivers are powerful message.
Also, I don't think he's talking about himself when he says he's through believing. Maybe going into character of someone who woke up from the lies. Great closing line for a character in the music video.
Actually, I do, Mr Smartypants. However, why don't you enlighten us all with yours?
Actually, I do, Mr Smartypants. However, why don't you enlighten us all with yours?
I really like your interpretation too. Though I'm not american and I'm no expert in domestic politics in the US, I feel that this applys all over the world. Disparity is nowdays created by people who don't really have an understanding about the lives and problems of "regular people".
I really like your interpretation too. Though I'm not american and I'm no expert in domestic politics in the US, I feel that this applys all over the world. Disparity is nowdays created by people who don't really have an understanding about the lives and problems of "regular people".
Anyways, one of the best songs in the album which is btw much better than its predecessor :)
Anyways, one of the best songs in the album which is btw much better than its predecessor :)
I'm not American either, it seems to me like it's summing up whats wrong with society. The first part focuses on 'being born with a silver spoon' and your chances in life being related to what your parents did and the social class your family is in. This is backed up by: ''They feast from the lines While we settle from crumbs'' This is obviously talking about how the rich eat from linen tablecloths with ordinary people settle for the scraps that are left.
I'm not American either, it seems to me like it's summing up whats wrong with society. The first part focuses on 'being born with a silver spoon' and your chances in life being related to what your parents did and the social class your family is in. This is backed up by: ''They feast from the lines While we settle from crumbs'' This is obviously talking about how the rich eat from linen tablecloths with ordinary people settle for the scraps that are left.
''Is this a handout undeserved? Or a just reparation?'' This asks whether some of the state handouts are generous or to keep citizens quite.
''If theres a God you better pray That this sleeping giant never wakes'' This is an eerie foreshadowing of EU Riots, and the internet fueled Anon and Occupy protests.