Lyric discussion by SubsterX 

The middle part starting with "and when I told her I didn't love her anymore" reminds me of Bat for Lashes' "What's a Girl to Do" in terms of lyrics and sound.

it's actually the lyrics from "He Cried" by The Shangri-las. they just switched the gender.

acutally, i just remembered the Shangri-las covered "He Cried"...there's an orignal called "She Cried". that's most likely the one The Horrors quoted.

An error occured.