The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald Lyrics
Well, first of all, it is a song about a FREIGHTER, NOT a tanker. And the slow, funeral like dirge melody brings to mind a cold, slate-grey lake and a sad sense of hopelessness. Lightfoot has painted an aural picture that is hard to forget, and the song endures because of it. The Fitzgerald was lost in a hurricane storm in Canadian waters just shy of Whitefish Bay in Lake Superior on the 10th of November, 1975. The "Musty old Hall in Detroit" mentioned in the song, is Mariners Church at the mouth of the tunnel exit in Detroit. The song pays fitting tribute to real men, doing what a real husband and Daddy should do. Work to provide food for their families. They were killed on the job. Nameless facelless, yet heros nonetheless.
This is the most magical of the Lightfoot songs I grew up with in the '70s (and they were all pretty magical to me at the time).
In the head of a kid on the shores of Lake Erie... "wait, there's a legend of these Great Lakes?, from the INDIANS?" "and there's history, you mean stuff HAPPENED here? Even RECENTLY?" Which it was, the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald occuring when I was eight.
I think this amazing ballad not only forever commemorates the grim reality for the 29 victims of the wreck (and their families), but catches the imagination in so many ways of those not personally affected by the loss.
It has a timelessness to it - like others have said here, this could've been about a famous wreck 100 years ago - or, drop a few of the technicalities - and it could be about a famous wreck of 500 years ago. It picks up a single thread of dark reality (one recent deadly shipwreck) and we add it to the constant - man's historic fight against "the sea" - or in this case, the Lake.
Gordon Lightfoot has recently altered a lyric in live performances.
He sings "At 7pm, it grew dark, it was then", replacing "At 7pmm a main hatchway caved in.."
Mr Lightfoot explains that this particular line was based on conjecture.
A recent History Channel documentary concluded that improperly secured hatches played no role in the sinking.
The lyrics were modified to clearly remove deck-crew negligence as a causal factor.
That's pretty cool, that he's willing to alter the song lyrics to properly reflect what we now know about the circumstances of the sinking.
That's pretty cool, that he's willing to alter the song lyrics to properly reflect what we now know about the circumstances of the sinking.
It really doesn't matter in my eyes if information is incorrect: it's all just a story.
It really doesn't matter in my eyes if information is incorrect: it's all just a story.
Excuse me there, I meant to say that Lightfoot was conveying the incident into a storytelling song. I don't care if the hatchways gave in or not. That's my opinion.
Excuse me there, I meant to say that Lightfoot was conveying the incident into a storytelling song. I don't care if the hatchways gave in or not. That's my opinion.
A fitting tribute to the tragic sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzergald, which might have been forgotten by now had it not been for this song.
In modern performances, Gordon Lightfoot changes two parts of the lyrics. The line "At 7 p.m. a main hatchway caved in, he said" is now sung as "At 7 p.m. it grew dark, it was then he said". This was after evidence was unearthed that found that there was no human error involved in the sinking of the ship. In addition, the "musty old hall" of the church is now described as being a "rustic old hall".
It's not fully agreed as to what caused the sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, but the most likely theory was rogue waves. The ship was crossing Lake Superior in very stormy weather, and the lake has been known to produce exceptionally tall 'rogue' waves in these conditions.
The legend that Lake Superior "never gives up her dead" has a basis in fact. Normally, when someone drowns, the body will float to the surface after a few days, due to the decomposition bacteria producing bubbles. But Superior is too cold to allow these bacteria to thrive.
This song gives me chills. My uncle's family used to own a fishery and would often have ships out on the great lakes and we'd hear stories all the time that are exactly like what this song is saying.
I've been listening to this song some 37 years now and still get chills every time.
It's easily Lightfoot's best song about a frieghter, aptly named the Edmund Fitzgerald, carrying a heavy load of taconite, or small iron ore pellets, sank as a result of 27-30 foot waves on a trip from Superior, Wisconsin to Detroit Michigan on Lake Superior on November 10, 1975. It was true that the ship was due course to Detroit and not cleveland, but the taconite was headed to Cleveland via Highway from Detroit. At 7:10 p.m. the ship's final chilling radio message to a sister ship was "We're holding our own".
@robinjay490 I know you just forgot some punctuation or something, but I cracked up when I read "It's easily Lightfoot's best song about a freighter".
@robinjay490 I know you just forgot some punctuation or something, but I cracked up when I read "It's easily Lightfoot's best song about a freighter".
I agree with the lines everyone has pointed out has haunting but i would like to add the best
"And all that remains is the faces and the names Of the wives and the sons and the daughters."
This song touches the hearts of anyone who has been in the Navy, Merchant Marines or Coastguard. I think that the song reminds us of how mortal we all are.
Although the Edmund Fitz was headed for Detroit, not Celvleand it is still a great song. Also Lake Erie does flow into Ontario.
Being from Wisconsin and livng 5 miles from the Lake and seeing freighters come in to port on a regualr basis really makes you wonder how a ship that large could sink without a distress call going out.
The Edmund Fitzgerald was over 700 feet long 70 feet wide and 30 feet tall and it sank in less than 1 minute.