"The First Time (Natalie's Song)" as written by David Hodges, Emanuel Kiriakou, Lindy Robbins and Andrew Goldstein....
Calm down, pull yourself together
It’ll be alright.
Regrets, you’re so completely useless,
But I can’t, go back.

But if she wanted me to stay,
How could I go?
I should have known it was the first time.
You can’t be giving back what you take, it’s all on me.
I can’t believe it was the first time

I wonder, how she will remember me,
As time goes by.
Was it just,
How she was imagining?
If I called tonight,
Would she tell me why?

But if she wanted me to stay,
How could I go?
I should have known it was the first time.
You can’t be giving back what you take, it’s all on me.
I can’t believe it was the first time.

Did it mean, everything?
‘Cause I can feel her tears fall to the ground.
Would it be like, the first time?
Oh…

But if she wanted me to stay…

You can’t be giving back what you take, it’s all on me.
I can’t believe it was the first time.
Yeah, yeah, ha-ah-ah…

I can’t believe it was her first time.



Lyrics submitted by Kitkat152

The First Time (Natalie's Song) song meanings
Add your thoughts

2 Comments

sort form View by:
  • +1
    General CommentThis is def my favorite song off the album.
    But I think it's about a girl wanting to have sex with him, him agreeing, then finding out that she gave her virginity to him.
    dannidjon August 08, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General CommentI agree with dannidj. it is definatly about a girl losing her virginity, but more importantly i think it's about the effect on him. He feels guilty that he rushed things and just left afterwards... also i think this guy's a player and this the first time he's actually thinking about what he does.
    laxstickchickon October 28, 2009   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain