I was backstage at a festival in Germany
Talking to a cute, fair skinned brunette
I asked her if she wanted to have a beer
and if she liked our set
I noticed that her hair was longer in the back
I figured that's cuz she's canadian
That's why I was surprised when she told me she was fully lesbian
That's when I realized it was Sara
or maybe it was Tegan
I'm pretty sure that it was Sara
Cuz Johnny Samson said she was the cool one
I told her that I was a big fan of her band
She asked me if I had a favorite song
I admitted that I never actually heard them
But I like K.D. Lang
I told her this Jew knows about the Junos
and how they got robbed three times in a row
And then I asked her if she knew of anyone who's selling pills or blow
That's when I creeped out Sara
Or maybe I just pissed her
off when I asked her if her sister
And her had ever had a threesome
Where they both ganged up on one girl
A fourgy or a fivesome
Do they think strapons are groovy
And had they ever seen the movie
"Bound", and did they like Jenifer Tilly
Did they like Jennifer Tilly
Sara said she
Preferred Gina Gershon
Angelina Jolie
In a "Gia" movie
That was on HBO
And "If these walls could talk"
Made Tegan cry alot
After that I almost forgot what she said
That's the problem with Diazepam
So many things I don't remember
But I got a sinking feeling
It's not that i'm a clairvoyant
But I think I creeped out Sara
I was creeping out on Sara
I hope it wasn't Tegan
Cuz Skiba said she is the cooler one

Lyrics submitted by GreenCorn41

Creeping Out Sara song meanings
Add your thoughts


sort form View by:
  • +2
    General Comment"I asked her if her sister
    And her had ever had a threesome
    Where they both ganged up on one girl
    A fourgy or a fivesome
    Do they think strapons are groovy"

    Ah these are the truly important questions that need to be asked
    Sakoon November 03, 2010   Link
  • +1
    My OpinionI love this song; classic NOFX humor.
    I'm going to go on a whim here and saying he's mocking Sara (from Tegan & Sara (the sister band, they're both lesbians)) for turning him down.
    This song is fabulous though; it's a fun summer song to drive to.
    Jhiggyon June 17, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General CommentOk so the lyrics are fairly self explanatory, it is a true story where Fat Mike was drunk and hanging out backstage at a festival and was talking to Tegan Quin of the Canadian duo Tegan & Sara and yes he creeped her out

    It turns out that it was Tegan and not Sara that he creeped out. Because Fat Mike honestly didn't know weather he was creeping out Sara or Tegan they released two versions of the song. Creeping Out Sara was released on NOFX's album Coaster however the vinyl release titled Frisbee contained the song Creeping Out Tegan. Creeping Out Sara was released as the single

    The song caused a bit of a stir but from fans of T&S but as Fat Mike explained in interviews - he was not being mean to them - he's the one who looks like a creep in the end.

    Tegan responded to the song on twitter saying "nofx + t/s = lots of email/texts/blogs/phone calls. i think punk in drublic is a great record. we r lesbians. sara was creeped. i AM cooler."

    The song is also not anti-gay in anyway - NOFX are very supportive of the GLBT scene and as Fat Mike says thay are a very gay positive band


    Johnny Samson is the former bass player for Propagandhi and now singer & guitarist for The Weakerthans

    "Skiba" is Matt Skiba - lead singer and guiratist of Alkaline Trio
    Chupachupon January 12, 2012   Link
  • 0
    My OpinionA boy once sent me this song. I thought it was pretty good, but I was a little biased.
    jillferon April 14, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General CommentThis song is really cool and funny...
    This part: But I like K.D. Lang ... I hear: But I like anyway
    Maybe i'm mistaken but it would be funnier
    melnofxon April 20, 2009   Link
  • 0
    My OpinionJust an awesome song.
    Or maybe it was Tegan. I'm pretty sure that it was Sara.
    With We called it America best song on the album so far. Fortune smiled on me, I found this alb at random :D
    Cornflexon April 29, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Commentdid he just make fun of matt skiba in there?
    William_B.on July 28, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Commentgeez Skillersky, take a joke! im sure that teagan and sarah can look after themselves! its just a funny song why go getting all down on fat mike ;)
    huntingbears86on April 11, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General CommentI think the song is really funny, and the whole skiba comment was to balance the johnny samson line... like have someone think a different sister is the cooler one. the music is totally generic though, but I think that's the point, laugh at it and that's it
    myrthalitaon August 22, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General CommentI love both songs. Creeping out Tegan & Creeping out Sara are both hilarious. I hope that it is true that they took no offense to this song. That would definitely be pretty awesome of them. There are a few differences throughout on Frisbee- the vinyl version of Coaster.
    kanoe13on July 03, 2012   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top